Winter Boot Buying Guide

Text by: Kelsey Begg.

Boots, Hush Puppies, Merrell, Saucony, Sorel, Sperry Top-Sider, The North Face, Wolverine. Winter Boot Buying Guide

It’s that time of the year that most children (myself included back in the day) dread, where the store shelves are stocked full with back-to-school supplies and fall gear. The sure sign that late, summer nights hanging out at the lake or camping in the woods counting the stars are coming to an end. But rather than being down about the season change, let’s get stoked for shopping for new winter boots!

There are a few important features to consider when shopping for winter boots other than the style and the fashionista factor. Yes the look of a winter boot will play a large roll in the decision-making process, but the technical features are equally as important. – Where and when you plan to wear your winter boots will influence the variety of technical features that may or may not appeal to you.

As we know, winter is generally colder than the rest of the seasons depending on the climate where you are living so adequate gear is imperative. Due to the more extreme temperatures, proper gear is essential for not only your comfort, but for your safety too, (and of course to ensure your experience is exceptional) so make sure you’re picking the right pair of winter boots with the help of this winter boot buying guide.


Temperature ratings for winter boots are similar to the temperature rating systems for sleeping bags in the sense that they are used more as a guideline to follow. While shopping for winter boots, the temperature ratings are a good comparison tool if you are struggling to choose between multiple models.

Shop UGG Australia Winter Footwear

UGG Australia Men's Larus

It is worth considering though, that like sleeping bags, different boots will be more suited to different people and for different activities for a number of factors including health, activity, environment and even as simple as your sock choice.

Shop Sorel Winter footwear

Sorel Women's Alpha Pac Xt

Keep in mind the type of usage you wish to get from your winter boot. Are you looking for something more stylish just to wear around town like the UGG Australia Men’s Larus or are you looking for something to wear while romping around the woods on snowshoes like the Sorel Women’s Alpha Pac Xt? If you are choosing a pair of winter boots for activities where your feet may sweat lots, ensure that you are choosing an appropriate sock to wear with it.(think wool not cotton; Smartwool, Icebreaker, Wigwam, etc)

Winter Boot Liners and Breathability

There are numerous types of liners for snow boots whether they be pac boots (generally have removable liners), have a shearling lining (often found is most fashion winter boots) or thermal materials such as Thinsulate. (Thermal materials are often found in winter boots that are not equipped with removable liners.) Generally for outdoor activities such as hiking or snowshoeing, a pair of snow boots with a removable liner (pac boots) are ideal so that at the end of the day, the liner can be removed, dried and reinserted for the following day’s activities.

Breathability is another big factor when shopping for winter boots. If your feet are sweating, they are wet and if that wetness has nowhere to escape to, you will be left with a cold foot. In some environments, the proper sock choice can be the difference between a wet foot and a dry foot and can save you from frost bite which would obviously put a damper on your outdoor activities.

Most boots are made with a combination of materials whether it be leather, nylon or Gore-Tex and with the different materials comes different properties.

  • In general, Gore-Tex boots are known for their waterproof and breath-ability features making them a top seller and a good all-around choice.
  • Boots made with nylon uppers and accents are generally more breathable but may not be as waterproof and would most likely require a waterproof coating (PU, DWR, etc.).
  • The opposite is true for all-leather boots; they’re waterproof but not as breathable.

For those who have feet that are more prone to sweating, a Gore-Tex winter boot with adequate breathability features will help keep you comfortable and dry for the duration of your activities. If ever in doubt, as mentioned above, your sock choice will also play a large roll in the environment inside your winter boot.

If you are participating in winter activities in warmer temperatures, a regular wool sock would be suffice. If you are someone with sweatier feet and are participating in activities in colder temperatures, a sock liner may be ideal as well as a warm, wool sock. The liner extracts the water and sweat from your foot and the wool sock will keep your foot warm.

Temperature Ratings For Winter Boots

There are four main temperature ratings for winter boots; -10, -20, -30, -40. Keeping in mind that like for sleeping bags, the temperature rating is a guideline, so if you know you are going to be in -25 weather, pay the few extra dollars for the -30 rating to ensure that you’ll still feel your little toes at the end of your winter adventure.


If you are looking for winter boots for more milder temperatures that are around zero or slightly below, a pair of snow boots with a temperature rating between 0 to -25 would be suffice. Generally these models will be moderately insulated (less than 400 grams of insulation) making them good for winter activities where the wearer will be exercising a great deal.

Adventurers embarking on multi-day winter expeditions or those living in areas with harsh, winter climates where temperatures drop well below the freezing level, a winter boot with a temperature rating between -40 to -70 would be adequate. These boots are going to be heavily insulated (around 400-600 grams of insulation) and in most cases, slightly heavier. These models may also include additional features to protect the wearer from the elements such as taller fits and/or gaiter-like uppers.

For the brave souls that tough out the winters in places where all you can do is sit and wait for the extreme, winter temperatures to wane, a pair of winter boots rated for -80 to -135 will be your salvation. These models are not generally used for wearers who are exerting themselves a lot, but more for activities such as ice-fishing where the wearer remains dormant (500-800 grams of insulation).

Traction of the Boot Sole

Have you ever stepped out of your house on a snowy day and stressed about every step you take wondering if you’re neighbours are going to get the glory to see you slip on the way to the bus once again? Avoid having to leave the house a half hour earlier just to prevent any faulty steps while navigating the icy, Montreal sidewalks and lace up yourself a sturdy, tacky pair of winter boots.

New this season, Vibram has come up with a new sole technology called Arctic Grip™. The sole of a shoe equipped with Arctic Grip™ will have Arctic Grip™ designated lugs that use the technology to grip wet, icy surfaces. If you look at the bottom of the shoe, these particular lugs can be specified as the ones with the blue or yellow specs.


On the sole of the shoes, there is also a white lug which is the thermochromatic lug. This particular piece will change from white to blue when the temperatures drop below 0 degrees Celsius.


The Arctic Grip™ sole can be found on a variety of models including Merrell, Sperry Top-Sider, Saucony, Hush Puppies and Wolverine and the following models can be purchased here at Altitude Sports:

  • Merrell Aurora Tall Ice+ for Women
  • Merrell Aurora Ice 6+ for Women
  • Hush Puppies Benson Rigby Ice for Men
  • Hush Puppies Parkview Ice+ for Men
  • Hush Puppies Action Parkview Ice for Men
  • Saucony Razor Ice+ for Men & Women

Sorel Women's Caribou Boot

Sorel Men's Caribou Boot

Most winter boots will have rubber soles such as the Sorel Caribou which has been one of their most popular models for years. Rubber soles are often chosen for winter boots due to the material’s waterproof properties making them ideal for snow, slush, puddles and any other wet, winter weather that may come your way.

Shop Sorel Footwear

Sorel Ankeny Mid Hiker

Sorel Tivoli 2 Premium


Other common winter boot soles include lugs which are generally made of rubber also and have deep indentations allowing for better traction on the ground. Lug soles are quite common in trail running shoes like the Salomon Speedcross models because of their traction on rough and slippery terrain making them great for winter conditions too. The North Face Back-to-Berkeley Redux Leather boot also has their version of lugs known as IcePick Temperature-sensitive lugs which can be found on other winter boot models.

Shop Salomon Footwear

Shop TNF footwear

Salomon Speedcross 4

TNF Back-to-Berkeley Redux Leather

Another common type of sole found on winter boots are the Vibram outsoles. These outsoles are known for their exemplary traction on a mix of surfaces as they are used on a wide range of footwear from winter boots to minimalist shoes. You can find Vibram outsoles on a variety of different winter footwear including some of TNF models.

Shop TNF Footwear

TNF Chilkat Tech Boot

TNF Hedgehog Hike Mid GTX


Traction is always a big concern for those who experience icier conditions where the tackiest rubber isn’t enough to ease their mind on icy sidewalks. In these climates where the amount of sand, salt or other de-icing chemicals aren’t tough enough against the elements, a sturdy pair of winter boots can be paired with a pair of slip-on crampons for ultimate traction. Most winter boots are compatible but it’s always best to do a little research so you don’t purchase something you are not able to even use.


Comfort and Sizing

Sure the boots look really cute but if you can’t bear wearing them because you’ve got blisters the size of toonies in all the wrong places, you may need to rethink your priorities. Not everyone’s feet are the same shape or size so don’t be shy. You may need to try on one, two maybe even five pairs before you find the right fit. There’s nothing worse than sitting with sopping wet socks all day because you can’t wear your winter boots without wincing in pain with every step.

A comfortable, winter boot should offer some arch and foot support and promote a proper walking posture. Some winter boots may feel heavier and a bit sluggish so it’s best to check a variety of models to find what works best for you. Some use more lightweight materials so you’re not dragging your feet with every step and are quite common in kid’s snow boots for this very reason. If you’re not used to heavy footwear due to wearing sandals or sneakers majority of the time, you may find the heavier, winter boots will fatigue your legs over the duration while you’re wearing them.

If you can, it is always best to try on winter boots with the winter socks (thin or thick) that you will be wearing most often. It is a common misinterpretation that winter boots should be purchased in a size larger in order to accommodate thicker socks. Whether you wear thin or thick socks, it is a personal preference. Keeping that in mind, when trying on winter boots, always start by trying on your shoe size and work your way up or down from there. Sizes can vary quite substantially within different brands and some styles will have liners that will pack-out over time.



Waterproof and Climate-proof Features

Winter boots are made to not only keep your feet warm but to to keep your feet dry too; wet feet are more likely to become cold feet. Most winter boots will be made up of a waterproof material like Gore-Tex or a waterproof leather and other models will not. Winter boots that are made of materials such as nylon that aren’t generally waterproof may be treated with a PU coating making them either water resistant or waterproof. Other brands such as The North Face, will have their own waterproof membrane such as TNF’s HydroSeal.

Other features found on winter boots to keep the wearer’s feet dry include a gusseted tongue, a cuff or a gaiter. These features may be small but they work hard to keep the elements out and the warmth and dryness inside the boot.

For Winter boots that aren’t quite tall enough, gaiters can be purchased separately and are compatible with most footwear. If you own a shorter, ankle-height winter boot but need a little extra height for the rogue snow storm that makes a surprise appearance every couple of years, you can throw on a pair of gaiters to give yourself that little bit of extra protection.

Some boots will have toggles and others will use laces, in either case, there’s no one that is better than the other. For some, the simplicity of toggles makes for a more convenient boot and are ideal for young children. I myself have the Sorel 1964 Premium LTR Boot which has laces up the front and I love them! They keep my feet warm and dry while cruising around town to and from work and feel like a slipper after a day on the hill in ski boots.

Pick what works for you. Your winter boot will be your number one accessory for the duration of your winter season so let you personality show!

It’s About More Than Just Looks

Finding a practical, good-looking pair of winter boots can be a lengthy process but it isn’t impossible! Many brands are working hard to combine practicality and functionality to create winter boots that are appealing to everyone whether they be strutting their stuff down the city sidewalks, or just keeping their feet warm after a day on the hill.

With winter comes extreme temperatures and conditions so ensure that your comfort and safety are a number one priority while shopping for a new pair of winter boots before the season starts. Happy, dry tootsies make for a happy you! Don’t wait until the snow starts to fall and get prepared for your future, outdoor activities this winter.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *